Methodology: How the Defensibility Check Works

Quick answer: The free check is a short, weighted questionnaire—not an official SPRS calculator and not a CMMC assessment. It scores answers about scope, SSP/evidence alignment, scoring integrity, and signature readiness, then places you in a defensibility band with next steps. The separateSPRS worksheet does the 110-row 1/3/5 arithmetic from DoD Assessment Methodology v1.2.1 Annex A.

What we designed for

  1. Never require CUI or SSP uploads
  2. Surface optimism patterns that create signature risk
  3. Stay fast enough for owners and IT leads to finish
  4. Point you to deeper guides—not fake certification

Question themes & weights

ThemeWhy it mattersRelative weight
Scope & CUI pathsUnknown boundaries invent false maturityHigh
SSP vs. operationsNarrative must match realityHigh
Evidence for “implemented”Claims without artifacts fail reviewHigh
Scoring integrityWrong weights produce fictional totalsHigh
POA&M hygieneHidden gaps reappear under scrutinyMedium
Independent challengeSingle-scorer bias is commonMedium
Signature courageThe human risk surfaceHigh

Result bands

Results fall into comparative bands (strong / mixed / weak / critical). Use them to prioritize work—not as pass/fail certification outcomes. Approximate index bands:

BandIndex (approx.)Ops interpretation
Strong≥ 80Better documentation habits—still verify evidence before any SPRS affirmation
Mixed55–79Gaps likely under review; rebuild weak rows before signing
Weak30–54High optimism risk; pause signature; run status mapping
Critical< 30Core defensibility elements missing; treat any current score as provisional

SPRS worksheet (separate tool)

The SPRS score worksheet is a 110-row calculator. Weights come from Annex A of the DoD Assessment Methodology v1.2.1. Marks stay in the browser. MET without an evidence type deducts the full weight. Partial credit is only for 3.5.3 and 3.13.11. 3.12.4 is not scored. A POA&M does not convert NOT MET to MET. The working total is not an official SPRS submission.

After the check — ops handoff

The 10-question check does not produce a 110-control register. Next artifacts:

  1. CUI / in-scope map
  2. SPRS worksheet (official weights)
  3. Status mapping method + CSV template
  4. Evidence locker sample
  5. Gap analysis process
  6. Optional: Pro Pack or paid SKUs

What we never claim

  • An official SPRS score (including the 110-row worksheet)
  • CMMC Level status or certification
  • Legal conclusions under the False Claims Act
  • That software alone replaces assessor judgment
  • That Brilliant at the Basics replaces 800-171 / DFARS 7012

Why we ask for contact details

Name and work email unlock your results and let us follow up if you want help interpreting them. SeePrivacy.